Year
Champions
Runner Up
1933
Christ Presbyterian Homecrest Baptist
1934
Disputed Between Christ Presbyterian
and Homecrest Baptist
1935
St. Bartholomew Lutheran Christ Presbyterian
1936
St. Bartholomew Lutheran Christ Presbyterian
1937
St. Bartholomew Lutheran  
1938
St. Bartholomew Lutheran Christ Presbyterian
1939
St. Bartholomew Lutheran Christ Presbyterian
1940
St. Bartholomew Lutheran St. James Episcopal
1941
St. Bartholomew Lutheran Christ Presbyterian
1942 - 1945
Suspended
War Years
1946
Christ Presbyterian Greenwood Methodist
1947
Christ Presbyterian St. Bartholomew Lutheran
1948
Christ Presbyterian St. Bartholomew Lutheran
1949
Christ Presbyterian St. Bartholomew Lutheran
1950
Christ Presbyterian St. Bartholomew Lutheran
1951
St. Bartholomew Lutheran Christ Presbyterian
1952
St. Bartholomew Lutheran Christ Presbyterian
Year
Champion
Runner-up
Third Place
1953
St. Bartholomew Luth. Christ Presbyterian  Olivet Baptist
1954
 St. Bartholomew Luth. Hillcrest Lutheran Christ Presbyterian
1955
 Hillcrest Lutheran St. Bartholomew Luth. Christ Presbyterian
1956
 St. Bartholomew Luth. Hillcrest Lutheran Prospect Pres.
1957
 Prospect Pres. Greenwood Methodist Christ Presbyterian
1958
 Prospect Presbyterian Christ Presbyterian Greenwood Meth.
1959
Greenwood Meth. Hillcrest Lutheran Prospect Pres.
1960
League split into two divisions